| COMMENT SHEET NUMBER ONE | |
| COMPARISON OF FINAL DRAFT ESSAY ONE AND EVALUATED DRAFT ESSAY ONE | |
| Using the scale below, please rate questions one through five. Place the appropriate letter in the blank provided at the end of each question. | |
| A. strongly disagree | |
| B. disagree | |
| C. neither agree nor disagree | |
| D. agree | |
| E. strongly agree | |
| 1. Because I received only minimal guidance from the instructor concerning the initial submission of essay number one, I struggled with the rough draft of the essay. | C |
| 2. I felt confident about my writing skills when I submitted my final draft of essay one. | B |
| 3. When I received my evaluated copy of essay number one, I was satisfied with my score. | D |
| 4. After reviewing the evaluated copy of essay number one, I recognized that many of the weaknesses pointed out were in areas with which I am familiar. | E |
| 5. I found peer review to be a valuable component of my writing process. | A |
| After comparing your rough draft to the evaluated final draft of essay one, you should be able to gauge the state of your writing skills at the start of the semester. Provide a well-structured paragraph in response to each of the following (two separate paragraphs). | |
| How did the comparison help you to identify your writing strengths?The comparison showed me where I was doing good at. This help me identify my writing strengths by showing me how they were and making me realize that it was done the right way. | |
| How did the comparison help you to understand your writing weaknesses?It helped me understand my weaknesses by highlighting them and then have the professor explain what was wrong with it. Most of the mistakes that I saw I knew I was bad at I just didn’t know how to fix them. Since then i feel that i have gotten better at those areas that i was struggling on at first. |